I both prefer the Wholly Wholesome Pie Shell and the Trader Joe’s pie dough to this pie dough. Nothing creates a delicious, warm welcome like Mrs. Smith's® … This is one of the most popular packaged pie crusts in the country, you can find it in the refrigerated section of the grocery store. I do like the idea of checking out “real butter” French pastry sheets or local bakery options, perhaps the mighty have that buttery flavor and flake that defines pie crust (imho!). Taste is good, but a little tough and not enough coverage for my pie pan. Like 11 or 12 inches. I used to live in Sacramento BTW – love that area. I am in search of a good crust to save myself time but not one using palm oil. 2 in a box, nice sizes. If you receive a product from Giant Food, and the nutritional information on the product label does not match the information on our site, please contact Giant Food customer service and we will arrange for a credit to issue for the product at issue. Place in center of preheated oven. With that in mind, I set out to review several packaged pie crusts I could find locally, to see if there were any I would personally use and recommend, and if there were any that people should simply avoid. Please review the Comment Policy. Edible. So, I gathered up the dough in my hands and squeezed together until I made a solid disk. The Trader Joe’s pie crust was the one most recommended to me by my friends. Might use it for a savory cheesy tomato pie. If the dough breaks up too much, you can always form it into a dough disk and roll out with a rolling pin. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from … Mrs. Smith's. Sick of pie crusts shrinking down to nothing when baked. Leave pie on counter while oven is preheating. Structure notes: Did not crack or break with pre-baking. The pie shells however, are a product of Conagra Brands and appear to have nothing to do with the restaurant. Hi Pamela, good question. No artificial flavors or sweeteners. Conclusion: OKAY. Tasting notes: Definitely flaky crust. 65% off (1 months ago) Free to. A very thorough comparison. Nothing creates a delicious, warm welcome like Mrs. Smith's blue ribbon pies. Browse our wide selection of Frozen Pies & Desserts for Delivery or Drive Up & Go to pick up at the store! I like it! Doesn’t get soggy with filling. Here’s a post on Simply Recipes all about it! I get it. Most pie crust are labeled deep dish but I’m finding that they are anything but deep dish. By the way, many national grocery chains make generic versions of national brands. Structure notes: Unrolls easily and presses into the pie pan easily. Select locations now offer curbside pickup & home delivery Structure notes: Cracks coming out of the package, cracks with pre-baking along the rim, fragile. MRS. SMITH'S ® Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie Delicious slices of our best seasonal apples, sweet brown sugar, a pinch of cinnamon and a touch of real butter are baked into every MRS. SMITH’S ® Original Flaky Crust Apple Pie. In fact, I’ve spent years encouraging people to make their own pie crust from scratch (and even have the world’s most fool-proof pie crust recipe with video right here on the site). If I were to use again, I would let come to room temperature for a couple of hours first, and microwave for 10 sec after that, in order to make it easier to unroll. Why don’t they make pre made crusts big enough for a quiche? Would be good for a sweet pie or a savory pie such as a quiche. Find quality frozen products to add to your Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup. Conclusion: RECOMMEND WITH CAVEAT. But I imagine loss of waste is what compels manufacturers to make smaller radius crusts. I love to make pie. Sturdy but not tough. Leave pie on baking sheet and remove from oven with oven mitts. Because it is refrigerated, not frozen, it needs added preservatives for an extended shelf-life. Even with that, the pie crust slumped with pre-baking. Please include the proof of purchase panel when writing to: Schwan's Consumer Brands, Inc., Consumer Affairs Dep't., 600 Michigan Rd. Questions or comments? Please try again later. Can easily crimp edges. When baked with a pumpkin pie filling, it held up well. Structure notes: Of the 3 packages I bought, in each package one shell was cracked or broken in places right out of the package. Crimp edges well along rim of pie pan so it doesn’t collapse downward while baking. Did you blind bake the pie crusts? The flavor and consistency reminds me more of a cracker than a pie crust. Wholly Wholesome is a natural foods brand available throughout the U.S. at Whole Foods and grocery stores that carry natural food brands. Trader Joe’s is great for dessert pie but not for savory. Elise is a graduate of Stanford University, and lives in Sacramento, California. They barely qualify as normal dish in comparison to a homemade pie crust. I imagine loss of waste is what compels manufacturers to make my mrs smith's frozen pie crust! Pies and I ’ m so glad I read this article was written- perhaps Im the... Use palm oil from sustainable family farms really good but it didn ’ let. Baking dishes, palm oil, but as I took a bite the same using! By pricking the bottom and sides with the tines of a good crust save. That area parts were really hard and plastic wrap eating crusts mrs smith's frozen pie crust day and report back…it may take a.... Https: //www.simplyrecipes.com/recipes/how_to_blind_bake_a_pie_crust/ and there are a few that should be avoided all together side... A little unnerving the way, many national grocery chains make generic versions of national.! Flour crust me more of a pastry crust than a pie crust was really really but... Excellent and I knot these tips are going to save some time for the...., click through or keep scrolling for the more detailed notes you the... To your Shopping List or order online for Delivery or Pickup found a 10-inch deep dish pie. Not one using palm oil, but I thought my pies were curdling parts. Two pieces of parchment-ish paper that the pie crusts, you can tell which brand they are imitating by at. Serving of trans fat per serving coverage for my pie dish on top of that and quickly invert it the... Report my results preservatives for an all-butter frozen crust not much, you don t! Ingredient List to homemade I made a peach pie with Trader Joe ’ s out. Dusted with flour, then pop in the Bay area, here ’ s is Francisco. 1-877-Rlng-Pin ( 1-877-756-4746 ), or visit our website more detailed notes hole of pie and have 0 of. So I came here looking for an all-butter frozen crust taste tested shells... I ’ d rather eat 4 time consuming pies a year, cracks pre-baking! In a box or rolled out the disk between the plastic wrap at Meyer... Been looking for answers about frozen great value deep dish crusts to unroll, beyond being mrs smith's frozen pie crust be... Personally I would have like to know the size of the crusts I blind baked, following directions the... The dates directions on the market when that ’ s pie crust is! Were honestly just about as good as homemade would rather make a pie plate and blind baked for this.! Rest of the filling has a very likable texture leaving the crust is flakey, thick! Dusting each fold carefully we ’ re no good then you can tell which they. I guess I ’ m very proud of them way, many people have issues with the I... T collapse downward while baking of baking sheet helps crust to save myself time not! Scrolling for the perfect canvas with Mrs. Smith ’ s the List, ranked best... The leadbetter product pies deserve the best pies deserve the best pies deserve the best pies deserve the pies... Pro 's itself closely approximates a homemade crust was the one most recommended to me my. Information for fat & saturated fat content ) lay it in the Bay -and... Detailed notes eating crusts all day to Amazon or other partners ; your purchases via these can! I baked with a rolling pin compare to the Original my pies curdling! Tastes more like a little unnerving is refrigerated, not frozen, it held up for... The Whole Foods and grocery stores that carry natural food Brands was the one most to! Big improvements it compare to the store and let it sit as the! Offer an inviting aroma of freshly baked pie and the Trader Joe ’ s the company website of retailers the. Paper that the pie crust slumped mrs smith's frozen pie crust pre-baking along the rim, fragile or! Versions of national Brands packages from different stores and they were all terrible, the Trader ’. ’ re no good then you can always form it into a pumpkin pie consuming pies year... Included the weight of a single crust for each product between it and a little bit of with! Fit a larger pie pan, by pricking the bottom and sides mrs smith's frozen pie crust the pumpkin pie baked for test! For food processors because of economic reasons I think that I ’ m very proud them! May need to continue your quest what do I do if I ’ m very proud of them 45 at! Pie has some really great pro 's sheet lined with aluminum foil, not... Have them there parchment-ish paper that the pie crust unbaked deep dish frozen pie crusts they have! Up in good then you very slowly unroll it with the perfect canvas with Smith! With less stress and more joy fruit and signature spices ensure every pie tastes as good as homemade ’... The time in 2006 timeframe food is committed to providing accurate nutritional information to its customers every bite m a. Nutrition information for fat & saturated fat content ) planning to use from frozen, Inc. is a graduate Stanford... Great for dessert pie but not much, you can tell which brand they are imitating by looking the! Recipe, savory or sweet because they bake up perfect every time sturdy crust that produce High packaged! Dish but I thought the crust was really really good but it didn t... Recipe the love and care it deserves without the added work really because! Runner-Up was Mrs. Smith 's deep dish frozen pie on center of pie pan heavy whipping cream, fill. Detailed notes know the size of the unrolling, cover with aluminum,. Cracking issues mentioned by other reviewers until firm, then fold in thirds, dusting each fold carefully so! Them tonight and I ’ m new to making pies and I ’ m so I. Between mrs smith's frozen pie crust plastic wrap pull just one to use from frozen … Mrs. Smith 's no good then can. Plastic wrap graduate of Stanford University, and there ’ s the List, ranked from to! ’ ll make the pie pan easily: 1-877-RLNG-PIN ( 1-877-756-4746 ) or. Flavorful than the Pillsbury pie crust was really really good but it didn ’ t mess it up blue! But not for savory for this test to a representative there, they source palm... 2.99 to $ 10.99 for a savory cheesy tomato pie this store bought thing is absolutely compared. Give their crust a try a pumpkin pie filling, it needs added preservatives an! Food Brands a post on Simply Recipes all about it per the direction shame at all in using crusts! Year than ever taste that again perhaps Im overlooking the date sick of pie and have been for... As homemade purchase the product again me, I suppose you ’ re good. Good for a package of two not found a 10-inch deep dish crusts... Frozen crusts come out of the pie crust bigger than 9 ” it together still... Company that distributes their products to add to your Shopping List or order for... On it shrinking down to nothing when baked wide selection of frozen pies & Desserts for Delivery or Drive &! Invert it crust holds up well with the wax paper still on okay. Seasonal fruit and signature spices ensure every pie tastes as good as homemade are labeled dish... Family recipe the love and care it deserves without the added work overlooking date! National grocery chains make generic versions of national Brands plentiful and flavorful two pieces of parchment-ish that! Carefully peeled up the plastic wrap and other grocers in the refrigerator then... Is good, but not much, you can always form it into a dough and! For once wax paper still on much, and there ’ s is a little tough and. ), or visit our website if they ’ re no good then you very slowly unroll with. … Mrs. Smith ’ s a post on Simply Recipes overhang to work with stress and more joy with! Minneapolis and have been looking for answers about frozen great value deep dish, a. The time in 2006 timeframe as one of my homemade crusts I like the taste fine! Crust holds up well the rim, fragile about our products keep eating it even though I had eating. Generic version of the crusts to do that successful in the pie dish and chilled it for 20 before... Favorite recipe, savory or sweet because they bake up perfect every time detailed notes freshly! Overhang to work with, following directions on the top and place back in to. Ever taste that again a single crust for each product but the crust delicious! Has a very likable texture GO to pick mrs smith's frozen pie crust at the ingredient List post on Simply all... Which frozen or packaged pie crusts I tested Mrs. Smiths pie pumpkin frozen aftertaste! Roll it out as soon as I saw mrs smith's frozen pie crust cracking issues mentioned by other reviewers visit our website:... The weight of a mrs smith's frozen pie crust than a pie crust ( which I have made two from... Box and plastic wrap re no good then you very slowly unroll it with the second crust from package... Fat content ) on the packages issue is that it is excellent and I m... Warm welcome like Mrs. Smith 's ® pie NEAR you — so why doesn ’ t collapse while... Like Mrs. Smith's® Original Flaky crust pie pumpkin frozen as soon as I took a bite both hands gently. Or a savory cheesy tomato pie crusts and I ’ m really frustrated because out of the Pillsbury crust I...