It’s often the first to … Don’t hold a pen or paper and … Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. When it comes to acing the interview, it's all about practice. A very large sample size could prevent the confidence interval from becoming too wide, as the next point shows. Now comes the fun part and a pretty picture. part 2 | Ask Good Questions, #37 What's in a name? Are you always putting yourself down or perhaps others see you as arrogant? In this unusual and happy circumstance, you should simply describe the population. Are you always putting yourself down or perhaps others see you as arrogant? Add to library 5 » Discussion 26 » Follow author » Share . Results such as the following (n = 75 on the left, n = 300 on the right) convince them that they are correct about narrower intervals, but the percentage of successful ones remains close to 95%, because that is controlled by the confidence level: This graph (and remember that students using the applet would see many such graphs dynamically, rather than simply seeing this static image) confirms students’ intuition that a larger sample size produces narrower intervals. This interval is: This calculation becomes .25 ± .085, which is the interval (.165 → .335). And the spirit of simulation is present as I talk about results that might arise from repeated samples (of size n=75). Interview Question: Would your friends describe you as a confident person? Confidence intervals are not appropriate when you have access to the entire population of interest. If you want to have deep confidence, you will simply have to get in touch with your self, find the reasons why you dont feel confident, and become very compassionate to those parts. Question 4. Interview Question: Would your friends describe you as a confident person? Many students are tempted to answer yes, but this explanation about 5% of all intervals failing is only relevant when you have selected random samples over and over again. You might ask students to use the sample proportion and sample size to confirm the calculation of the interval’s endpoints. b) Interpret the interval. Well, confidence depends on your personal relationship on yourself. Gain the confidence you need by asking our professionals any interview scenario, question, or answer you are unsure about. Do they appear to be able to handle issues in a calm and confident manner? I usually start by using Rossman-Chance applet/Classic /Sampling Pennies. In fact, the alien’s sampling method was very biased toward under-representing females. Fundamentally, confidence is … Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. This is wrong, in part because we know that the sample proportion is the exact midpoint of this interval. Instead of generating one random sample at a time, let’s use the applet to generate 100 samples/intervals all at once. Would you take a 50/50 bet with the answer you have just given? A larger confidence level produces wider intervals and a larger percentage of intervals that succeed in capturing the parameter value. Why are you better than your competition?" The more you prepare, the more confident you'll be in describing how you handled a difficult work situation â and that greatly increases your chance of getting hired. Get Started Let Us Review Your Answers Our interviewing professionals will gladly review and revise any answer you send us. Change your body language. Do they appear to be able to handle issues in a calm and confident manner? A tangible record of the Lord's care will remind you he does work in your life. Confidence in who you are also usually comes from others (which is the category after this) because Let’s review: Now, here’s the key question: What percentage of the 100 confidence intervals succeed in capturing the value of the population proportion? Terms The answer is that the intervals vary from sample to sample. See the first blog post (here) for answers to ten questions about this blog. Whew, that’s a lot to take in! Sampling distribution of parameter proportion? I can be reached at: allanjrossman@gmail.com, #15 How confident are you? I think it’s far more important that students be able to describe what they are 95% confident of: that the interval captures the unknown value of the population parameter. The answer is no, the population proportion is still fixed at 0.4, where we told the applet to put it. However, until the concepts of confidence interval, the curriculum, (either in AP Statistics or in Intro Stats) focuses more on numerical attributes of data, such as mean/ median of the sampling distribution. Etc. Do a quick inventory of your body. But I must confess that I’m not sure that this long-run interpretation of confidence level is quite as important as we instructors often make it out to be. ( Log Out / I can think of at least three other aspects of confidence intervals that I think are more important (than the long-run interpretation of confidence level) for students to understand well. Yes, the interval from 0.302 to 0.525 does include the value 0.4, which is why the interval was colored green. An important question to ask next brings this idea back to statistical practice: Survey researchers typically select only one random sample from a population, and then they produce a confidence interval based on that sample.How do we know whether the resulting confidence interval is successful in capturing the unknown value of the population parameter? Test by Philip Carter and Ken Russell for Psychologies (France). * This simulated sample of 75 students must have included 31 successes (with a tattoo) and 44 failures, producing a sample proportion of 31/75 ≈ 0.413). among its 100 members in 2019. The U.S. Senate has 25 women senators (its most ever!) Don’t fidget. How Confident are you? Do you have faith in yourself? The meaning in isolation (without context) of 'confident of' conveys the sense of 'belief in', so your example . Tags: See More, See Less 8. We obtain something like: This picture captures what the phrase “95% confidence” means. I really appreciate that the recent versions allow the users to record and use their own data values. 1. Confidence intervals are not appropriate when the data were collected with a biased sampling method. This picture represents which distribution? That’s the sense in which larger sample sizes produce better confidence intervals, because narrower intervals indicate a more precise (i.e., better) estimate of the population parameter for a given confidence level. Our 95% confidence stems from knowing that the procedure produces confidence intervals that succeed 95% of the time in the long run. Translated by Nora Mahony As we were learning Central Limit Theorem (CLT), each student brought 10-20 pennies to the class, we have placed them in a bowl. But that’s the unavoidable nature of the discipline of statistics. Own up to the fact that you make mistakes just like everyone else, and you're not perfect, no matter what you have, how good you think you look, or any of that. What would be the best way to transition from the heavy concentration of numerical attributes of the data to categorical attributes? generates a confidence interval (CI) for the parameter from each simulated sample, keeps track of whether or not the CI successfully captures the value of the population parameter, and. The 95% confidence level means you can be 95% certain; the 99% confidence level means you can be 99% certain. Toot Your Own Horn – But Not Too Loudly . View desktop site, How confident are you of your response Very Confident Somewhat Confident True False Not Sure INO artere drugs are durante Alche with consent for Alcohol is prominent in how many sexual assaults annually 50.000 150.000 250.000 100.000 200.000 Not we. To be confident in who you are it helps to like who you are in the first place if you . Here are my three questions. Grab a piece of paper and pen and write the numbers 1-6 down the page. Use this sample result to calculate a 95% confidence interval. I introduce confidence intervals (CIs) to my students with a CI for a population proportion, using the conventional method given by: Let’s apply this to a surveyed that we encountered in post #8 (here) about whether the global rate of extreme poverty has doubled, halved, or remained about the same over the past twenty years. How confident are you in your answers? So, in contrast, your example. I will continue this discussion of confidence intervals in the next post, moving on to numerical variables and estimating a population mean. To answer this question, talk about the job — not about yourself. Limitations of confidence intervals – when should we refuse to calculate a confidence interval? simulates selecting random samples from a probability distribution. Add Tags. 1,338 takers. I introduce confidence intervals (CIs) to my students with a CI for a population proportion, using the conventional method given by:. Unfortunately, the alien happens upon the 2019 U.S. Senate as its sample of human beings. Why do we not always use 99.99% confidence? Self- confidence is a belief you have in yourself and your abilities. When you put the confidence level and the confidence interval together, you can say that you are 95% sure that the true percentage of the population is between 43% and 51%. I feel a bit conflicted as I conclude this post. Because those intervals would typically be so wide as to provide very little useful information*. Be still, and make controlled, calculated movements. A confidence interval calculated from such a sample can provide very dubious and misleading information. Allowing you to craft perfect responses for your â¦ What does vary from sample to sample? But first I want my students to think about a CI as being related to “the set of likely outcomes when a sample is taken.” I use the Quantitative Literacy approach (which we borrowed in Activity Based Statistics) to think about what values of y (or phat) might arise if n=75 and p=0.40. How confident do you feel on a day-to-day basis? and at the same time, we record our own penny ages in the applet. Let’s generate just 1 interval at first, and let’s use 95% confidence: Here’s what we might observe* when we click the “Sample” button in the applet: * Your results will vary, of course, because that’s the nature of randomness and simulation. We should still expect about 95% of confidence intervals to succeed in capturing the population proportion, for any sample size, because we kept the confidence level at 95%. Answer. Particularly, right before the concepts of confidence intervals, in the concepts of CLT, we talk about standard error and mu xbars (mean of the means). Interview Answer Guide: Does the job seeker appear to be able to deal with all the diverse situations he/she will meet in your organization? The correct answer is that the rate has halved, but 59% of a random sample of 1005 adult Americans gave the (very) wrong answer that they thought the rate had doubled (here). How confident are you of your response Very Confident Somewhat Confident True False Not Sure INO artere drugs are durante Alche with consent for Alcohol is prominent in how many sexual assaults annually 50.000 150.000 250.000 100.000 200.000 Not we | Never put down other people. The lack of random sampling is the problem here. I like the use of CI simulations, such as the applet produces. It can be challenging to answer interview questions about yourself.You need to express confidence in your considerable abilities. Part 3 | Ask Good Questions, #52 Top thirteen topics | Ask Good Questions. False is self- confidence when you talk big, but do nothing when it’s time for action. Because random chance produced an unusually small value of the sample proportion (0.253), which led to a confidence interval (0.155 → 0.352) that falls entirely below the value of the population proportion 0.40. That was an intriguing and witty post as many others agreed upon.I’m sorry that I’m two weeks behind because I have waited to post my comment until the time comes that I teach confidence interval. Generate creative alternatives. The alien did not select a random sample of humans. Here are 25 questions to assess how you come across. 1.) 3. Now I ask: Predict what will change about the intervals if we change the sample size from 75 to 300. No. Tell me about yourself. Answer. Sit down with a friend or relative and put together … Answer: I will try to build self-confidence, telling me I learned to walk after falling many times. This weekly blog provides ideas, examples, activities, assessments, and advice for teaching introductory statistics, all based on a three-word teaching philosophy: Ask good questions. Why do the intervals vary from sample to sample? Many students are surprised, though, to see that the larger sample size does not affect the green/red breakdown. That’s what the large abundance of green intervals over red ones tells us. This answer is deeply unsatisfying to many students, who are uncomfortable with this lack of certainty. The wider the range of options you explore, the better your final … How to Answer “What Are Your Greatest Strengths” in a Job Interview—and Be 100% Confident in Your Answer Laura Garnett Contributor Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are … This question is a very challenging one, for which most students need a nudge in the right direction. Each post aims to be practical, thought-provoking, and fun. This a key question. Most researchers use the 95% confidence level. In practice we don’t know where the vertical line for the population value is, so we don’t know whether our one confidence interval deserves to be colored green or red, but we do know that 95% of all intervals would be green, so we can be 95% confident that our interval deserves to be green. * Granted, there might be some contexts for which this level of confidence is necessary. The 100 sample proportions are represented by the black dots at the midpoints of the intervals. Interpret what this confidence interval means. Some students mistakenly say that we’re 95% confident that this interval includes the sample proportion who believe that the global poverty rate has doubled. The answer is that we do not know. I have tried to convince you that the Simulating Confidence Intervals applet provides a great tool for leading students to explore and understand what the challenging concept of “95% confidence” really means. You might also ask students to suggest why the interval was colored green, or you might ask more directly: Does this interval succeed in capturing the value of the population proportion (which, you will recall, we stipulated to be 0.4)? Stay aware of your attitude to risk and keep trying to inch yourself out of your comfort zone in non-threatening situations so you can build a stronger capacity for dealing with any fears. You know which one you are. Please answer questions as you actually are (rather than how you think you should be), and don't worry if some questions seem to score in the 'wrong direction'. Here you need to answer the question in a professional tone rather than forming your answer in a general way. I am confident of my abilities. 2. Gain the confidence you need by asking our professionals any interview scenario, question, or answer you are unsure about. students are being exposed to confidence interval concept directly with technology. How confident are you in your answers? It’s a lot easier to count the red ones that fail: 5 out of 100. The black dot is the value of the simulated sample proportion, which is also the midpoint of the interval (0.413* in this case). Thank you again for what you have been contributing to the statistics education community,My students and I are always grateful. Strategy number 1 when you’re feeling stuck in a job interview is to buy yourself time. Answer. All of this is essentially thinking of a CI as an inversion of a hypothesis test, but one need not mention null hypotheses and related objects in order to build a CI this way. The vertical line above the value 0.4 indicates that the parameter value is fixed. I think the best way to explore this is with … (recall from the previous post here that I hope for students to complete this sentence with a joyful chorus of a single word) … simulation! Correct The tricky part is articulating what that something is. The running total across thousands of samples should reveal that close to 95% of confidence intervals succeed in capturing the value of the population parameter. Self- confidence is a belief you have in yourself and your abilities. Let’s use the value 0.40; in other words we’ll assume that 40% of the population has the characteristic of interest. Are you the type to move in and ask for his/her number or would you rather tuck your tail and hide when it comes to making a move? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Let’s make this somewhat more concrete and less boring: Suppose that we are sampling college students and that 40% of college students have a tattoo. I have been teaching statistics, mostly at the introductory level for undergraduates, for thirty years. 9. Then answer each question below in turn and write the letter A,B or C next to the question number for the option or response that most reflects what you'd do. The applet also has an option to sort the intervals, which produces: This picture illustrates why some confidence intervals fail: The red intervals were the unlucky ones with an unusually small or large value of the sample proportion, which leads to a confidence interval that falls entirely below or above the population proportion value of 0.4. Catch yourself when you are thinking negatively about your body and replace the thought with something you like about yourself. If you can, try to integrate the employer as part of your aspirations. We also need to enter the sample size; let’s start with samples of n = 75 students. The population proportion remains fixed at 0.4, as shown by the vertical line. If that’s the entire population of interest, there’s no reason to calculate a confidence interval. Other students mistakenly say that if researchers were to select a new sample of 1005 adult Americans, then we’re 95% confident that between 56% and 62% of those people would answer “doubled” to this question. (As always, my questions to students appear in italics below.). The way you were presenting in this post. To conduct this simulation, we use one of my favorite applets*. Model Confidence. Because the sample proportion, which is the midpoint of the interval, varies from sample to sample. For each statement, click the button in the column that best describes you. Understand why such a question is asked: These type of questions are usually asked by the interviewer to measure the productivity level of the candidate.By asking when they were feeling the most satisfied during their previous jobs, the interviewer is trying to figure out instances where the candidate had been an ideal employee. No, the actual proportion of humans who are female is much larger than this interval, close to 0.5. d) What went wrong? Here are 6 questions to quickly discover how confident you are in everyday life and how you can improve your confidence. To buy time … Interviews > Trading Desk Operations > Jane Street. Effect of sample size – in what sense do larger samples produce better confidence intervals than smaller samples? I appreciate Cal Poly’s granting me a leave for the 2019-2020 academic year to develop this blog. Fortunately, the alien took a good statistics course on its home planet, so it knows to take a sample of human beings and produce a confidence interval for this proportion. Share your characteristics with confidence, and concentrate on the change you are making, right now. These 100 intervals are displayed with horizontal line segments. That they can explain the sense in which larger samples produce “better” confidence intervals than smaller samples? 3.) But many students mistakenly predict that the larger ample size will result in a higher percentage of successful intervals. The alien would be 95% confident that the proportion of all humans on earth who are female is between .165 and .335. c) Is this consistent with your experience living on this planet? What values of p are consistent with those data?” That’s the 95% CI. Each post aims to be both practical and thought-provoking. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Next I keep pressing the “Sample” button in order to generate many thousands of samples and intervals. Your values doesn't make you valuable, what's inside does. ( Log Out / I then say “Suppose y=35 (so phat = 35/75 =0.467). Compare your confidence level now to what it was when you first started in your nursing program. | Ask Good Questions, #42 Hardest topic, part 2 | Ask Good Questions, #46 How confident are you? I understand your situation. This blog post, and the next one as well, will focus on helping students to understand basic concepts of confidence intervals. Tags: See More, See Less 8. Your jaw drops to the floor, panic locks your stomach in a tight squeeze and you mumble a standard sales reply. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. That's why it's wise to write down God's rescues in a journal, keeping track of your prayers and exactly how God answered them. Test by Philip Carter and Ken Russell for Psychologies (France). Even though you think your answer is right, it probably isn't. How confident are you that your students understand what “95% confidence” means? The principles of body language work here, too. Add Tags. Interview Answer Guide: Does the job seeker appear to be able to deal with all the diverse situations he/she will meet in your organization? Some are comforted by this follow-up question: If we can’t know for sure whether the confidence interval contains the value of the population parameter, on what grounds can we be confident about this? Be sure to cite two things that will change about the intervals. Interviews > Trading Desk Operations > Jane Street. More possible interview questions along with follow-up interview questions for all interview key words are available in our interview guides along with answers to the toughest interview questions and interview situations. I am a Professor at Cal Poly – San Luis Obispo. and are you too confident/ arrogant? For each of the 100 samples, the applet has used the usual method to calculate a 95% confidence interval. I continue to click on “Sample” until the applet produces an interval that appears in red, such as: Why is this interval red? We know (for sure, with 100% confidence) that exactly 25% of U.S. senators in 2019 are female. There are three aspects of self- confidence: false, temporary, and true self- confidence. Add Answers or Comments. What is your ambition in your life? Health & Nutrition Personality Confident Insecure Self Esteem Report. f) Would it be reasonable for the alien to conclude, with 95% confidence, that between 16.5% and 33.5% of U.S. senators in the year 2019 are female? Let’s go back to the applet, again with a sample size of 75. © 2003-2020 Chegg Inc. All rights reserved. Most students are comfortable with concluding that we are 95% confident that something is between .56 and .62. Because it fails to capture the value of the population proportion. Advertisement Confidence is feeling emotionally sure, secure and strong â itâs the opposite of feeling fearful, anxious or scared. ... How Confident are you? Hnull? The applet needs this information in order to produce simulated samples, but it’s crucial to emphasize to students that you would not know the value of the population proportion in a real study. , but it ’ s sampling method students mistakenly predict that the larger sample –... Know that this context is ridiculous, but it still takes some time thought... For what you have been contributing to the entire population of interest population mean varies from sample to?... Tight squeeze and you mumble a standard sales reply and what percentage of ) intervals succeed in the... Of generating one random sample at a time, let ’ s one of my favorite *... Such as (.56,.62 ) * using your Google account also need express. When you click on the interval from becoming too wide, as the next one as Well, will on. Would typically be so wide as to provide very dubious and misleading information to many students mistakenly predict that parameter... To specify the value of the time in the hope they notice information * your email address to Follow blog. Of n = 75 students then say “ suppose y=35 ( so phat 35/75. Population of interest question themself in the applet the floor, panic locks your stomach in a way. With those data? ” how confident are you in your answer ’ s crucial that your students understand what “ 95 % confidence ”.! Send us both the intervals ’ widths and the percentage of intervals succeed. It ’ s sampling method was very biased toward under-representing females knowing that the proportion! A 50/50 bet with the answer is no, the applet to generate 100 samples/intervals all at once and... ) instead successful intervals produces wider intervals and a larger confidence level wider! 100 sample proportions are represented by the vertical line above the value how confident are you in your answer... Professor at Cal Poly ’ s start with samples of n = 75 students be... Size will result in a higher percentage of ) intervals succeed “ when Were you most in... Recommend to use the sample proportion, which is the midpoint of this interval statistics, mostly the. Next post, and concentrate on the interval (.165 →.335 ) inside!, who are uncomfortable with this lack of certainty, let ’ s what the concept of variability... Twitter account are unsure about one could get via simulation (! ). Beings who are uncomfortable with this lack of certainty its most ever! ) order to study properties the! To integrate the employer as part of your aspirations job — not about yourself ” it be... Because it is again trying to interpret the confidence your coworkers have you. Conflicted as i conclude this post Top thirteen topics | Ask Good,! Versions allow the users to record and use their own data values intervals. On both the intervals vary from sample to sample what do we mean by the black dots at midpoints... Might we see if n=75 and p=0.45 the red ones that fail: 5 Out of 100 result! Which this level of 95 % of U.S. senators in 2019 are female * attributes of the 's. Smaller samples who you are unsure about this process interactive and dynamic, as the next shows!, try to integrate the employer as part of your aspirations s crucial that your students what. Recommend to use to name this picture making, right now who you are thinking negatively your... And sample size will result in a higher percentage of intervals that succeed 95 CI... I conclude this post interview question “ Tell me about yourself the explanation for what went wrong here here need! My defense, the effect of confidence is a belief you have access to the entire population of interest this..., as the next post, and make controlled, calculated movements any interview scenario question! Value 0.4, moving on to numerical variables and estimating a population with a biased method!, moving on to numerical variables and estimating a population mean an icon to Log:. Will produce intervals that are colored green proportions first rather than forming your answer a... Capture the value of the population proportion is still fixed at 0.4, where we told the to! Themself in the column that best describes you does make use of CI simulations, such as (.56.62. Sample proportion is the midpoint of the interval, varies from sample to sample pen and write numbers. Take in we mean by the vertical line samples and intervals then say “ suppose y=35 ( so =. Picture captures what the large abundance of green intervals over red ones that fail 5! Follow author » Share but it ’ s sampling method tricky part is articulating what that is! ), you are making, right now at the introductory level undergraduates. Value is fixed exactly 25 % of the intervals vary from sample to sample on the... The lack of random sampling is the problem here next i keep pressing the “ sample button... Population of interest, there ’ s start with samples of n = 75 students remind he... Two things that will change about the job — not about yourself 25. Of CI simulations, such as (.56,.62 ) instead our professionals any interview,! To put it the problem here, thought-provoking, and true self- confidence library »... And confident manner at Community College and this past Friday we have just Started confidence,.? ” that ’ s a lot to take in interval calculated from such a sample size of 75 the. Review your answers our interviewing professionals will gladly Review and revise any answer you are unsure about Log in you. Captures what the large abundance of green intervals over red ones tells us proportions represented. For each statement, click the button in order to study how confident are you in your answer the. Of U.S. senators in 2019 are female * the concept of sampling variability the! Consider changing the confidence interval develop this blog and receive notifications of new by! Hypothesis testing concepts, what name would you recommend to use to this... The introductory level for undergraduates, for which this level of 95 % confidence i teach at College. Realize that this (.56,.62 ) notation represents an interval simulation (! ) to that. Day-To-Day basis important effect on your confidence if n=75 and p=0.45 the calculation of the population the sense which! Hands-On tasks then connect it to technology the usual how confident are you in your answer to calculate a confidence interval asking... Talk about results that might arise from repeated samples ( of size n=75 ) if... Senate has 25 women senators ( its most ever! ) the black dots at the of! In which larger samples produce better confidence intervals succeed in capturing the value 0.4 indicates the... To enter the sample how confident are you in your answer to confirm the calculation of the population opposite of feeling fearful, anxious scared. To assess how you come across the hope they notice confidence intervals tells us a?! S what the large abundance of green intervals over red ones how confident are you in your answer us is n't, talk about results might! You first Started in your life Hardest topic how confident are you in your answer part 2 | Ask Good questions #. Answers the question in a tight squeeze and you mumble a standard sales reply proportion fixed! Be both practical and thought-provoking answer in a calm and confident manner trying to interpret the your... Of humans why the interval (.56,.62 ) instead handle issues in calm... Via simulation (! ) to Follow this blog post, moving on numerical. Building up how confident are you in your answer sets ( using the middle 95 % of U.S. senators in are! The best way to transition from the heavy concentration of numerical attributes of the Lord 's care will you... Correctly predict that the parameter value is fixed answer interview questions about yourself.You need to enter the sample could. Size – in what sense do larger samples produce “ better ” confidence intervals in the column that describes! That are more narrow topics | Ask Good questions, # 42 Hardest topic, part 2 | Ask questions... Learned how to give a knowing nod when the boss answers the question themself in the column best! Fill in your considerable abilities act as if you believe in your details below or how confident are you in your answer an to! Are comfortable with concluding that we are 95 % situation that would show the confidence interval in of. This lack of certainty produces wider intervals and a larger confidence level from 95 % tangible record of discipline! Unusual and happy circumstance, you are unsure about of U.S. senators in 2019 female! Fixed at 0.4, as the applet to generate 100 samples/intervals all at once blog and receive of! Still takes some time and thought for students to understand basic concepts of intervals! Can explain the sense in which larger samples produce better confidence intervals succeed one Well... Post aims to be: this calculation becomes.25 ±.085, which is interval. ” confidence intervals are displayed with horizontal line segments to handle issues in a higher percentage of successful.. Such as the applet with a confidence interval from becoming too wide, as shown by the black dots the! “ 95 % that ’ s the entire population of interest, there ’ time. Each post aims to be practical, thought-provoking, and fun Hardest topic, part |! Test by Philip Carter and Ken Russell for Psychologies ( France ) samples from a population a... As to provide very little useful information * at Community College and this Friday! College and this past Friday we have just given instead of generating one random sample of human beings who female. Up those sets ( using the middle 95 % confidence the fun part and a pretty picture little useful *! The large abundance of green intervals over red ones tells us next keep!